The boundaries between the presidential duty of respect and the employee's right to express his opinion - a comparative study -
Keywords:
- The employee's right. - presidential respect. - freedom of expression.Abstract
One of the most prominent right enshrined in international treaties and national legislation at the constitutional level is the right to express opinion, given its importance in promoting various human rights, developing thought and evaluating performance. However, in practice, the use of this right often collides with duties and prohibitions that restrict the behavior of individuals and employees (within the scope of public office legislation), so that the use of this rights in public office has become a restriction that may affect the origin of the right. The administration can interpret the employee's behavior as a breach of the duty of respect . On the other hand, the employee can claim that he is exercising his right to express his opinion.
This scramble is the result of the overlap between the boundaries separating the duty of the employee to respect the administrative head and the right to express an opinion. This is why many disputes are raised before the administrative and ordinary courts, and although it adjudicates them with rulings that end the dispute, it did not set clear criteria that can be relied upon. In distinguishing between what is rights and what is duty. That is why we found that it is beneficial to delve into this topic and make it a material for our financial research.
References
-Anwar Sultan, General Legal principles, fourth edition, Dar Al-Nahda Al- Arabiya, Egypt, 1983.
-Jazzier, public function in the world.
-Hassan Muhammad Awada, The presidential Authority, Al- Alamiya press, Beirut, 1975.
-Hassan Mohamed Hind, The Legal System for freedom of Expression, House of legal Books, Egypt, 2004.
-Khamis Al-Sayed Ismail, Disciplinary Trials, Encyclopedias of Administrative Judiciary, Dar Mahmoud for printing, Cairo, 2003.
-Rafid Khalaf Hashim Al- Bahadli and Othman Salman Ghaylan Al-Aboudi, Legislation between Industry and Formulation, first edition, Baghdad, 2009.
-Suad Al- Sharqawi, Political Systems in the Contemporary World, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Egypt.
-Suleiman Muhammed al-Tamawy, Administrative Judiciary, Book Three, Disciplinary judiciary, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi, Cairo, 1987.
-Tariq Hassanein Al-Zayyat, Freedom of Opinion for the public Servant, Second Edition, Dar Al-Nahda-Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 1998.
-Asim Ahmed Aguila, Obedience to Superiors and its limits in the public office, Dar Al-Nahaa-Al- Arabiya, Egypt, 2000.
-Abdul Hamid Kamal Hashish, Studies in the public Service in the French System, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Egypt, 1977.
-Abdul Hamid Al-Shawarbi, Expressive Crimes, Press and publication Crimes, Dar Al-Kutub and Arab Studies, Alexandria, 2018.
-Abdul-Fattah Hassan, Discipline in the public office, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya-Egypt, 1999.
-Abdul Qadir Al-Sheikhly, The Art of legal Drafting (Legislation, Jurisprudence and Judiciary), Dar Al-Thaqafa Library for publishing and Distribution, Amman, 1995.
-Abdel Aziz Abdel Moneim Khalifa, Disciplinary Responsibility in the public Service, university Thought House, Egypt, 2011.
-Abdul Aziz Muhammad Salman, constitutional protection for Freedom of opinion in Jurisprudence and constitutional Judiciary, First edition, Dar Al-Fikr Al- Jami,i, Egypt, 2014.
-Abdel-Azim Abdel- Salam Abdel- Hamid, Disciplining the public servant in Egypt, First Edition, Part Two, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2000.
-Ali Juma Muhareb, Administrative Discipline in the public office (a comparative study), first edition, Dar Al-Thaqafa for publishing and Distribution, Jordan, 2004.
-Ali Khattar Shatnawi, Studies in the public Service, University of Jordan, Amman, 1998.
-Aliwa Mustafa Fath al-Bab, The Mediator in Enacting, Drafting and Interpreting Legislations, Book Two, Interpretation and Drafting of legislations, Shatan publishing House, Egypt, 2012.
-Mazen Lilo Radi and Haider Adham Abd al-Hadi, Human Rights and fundamental Freedoms, Dar Qandil, Amman, 2008.
-Mazen Lilo Radi, Obedience and its Limits in the public office, University press, Alexandria, 2002.
Mhomaed Refaat Abdel Wahhab, Administrative law, public officials System in Egypt, New University House, 2017. 24-Muhammed Abdel Hamid Abu Zaid, obedience to presidents and the principle of legitimacy, Dar Al- Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2005.
-Magdy Medhat Al-Nahri, Restrictions on the public Employee,s Exercise of fundamental Rights and freedoms, El-Galaa Modern Library, Mansoura, 2001.
-Muhammad Mukhtar Muhammad Othman, Disciplinary Crime between Administrative Law and Management Science, first edition, Dar Al- Fikr Al-Arabi, Cairo, 1973.
- Mustafa Mohamed El-Gamal and Abdel- Hamid Mohamed El-Gamal, The General Theory of Law, University House, Beirut, Lebanon, 1987.
-Noufan Al-Ajarmah, Authority to Discipline public Employees (a comparative study), first edition, Dar Al-Thaqafa for publishing and Distribution, Amman, 2007.
-Wissam Sabar Al-Ani, Administrative Judiciary, first edition, Al-Sanhouri Library, Baghdad, 2013.
Secondly: Theses and University theses
Theses
-Khaled Muhmmad Mustafa al-Mawla, The Competent Authority in Imposing Disciplinary penalties on public Employees in Iraq, PhD thesis Submitted to the college of Law, university of Mosul, 2001.
-Ali Gomaa Muhareb, Discipline in the public Service, a PhD thesis submitted to Ain Al-Shams university.
-Naim Attia, Contribution to the Study of the General Theory of Individual Freedoms, PhD thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Law, Cairo university.
-Muhammad Jawdat Al- Malt, The Disciplinary ReDsponsibility of the public Employee, PhD thesis, Dar Al- Nahda Al- Arabiya, 1968.
-Malike Al- Saroukh, Disciplinary authority in the public office between the administration and the Judiciary, PhD thesis Submitted to the Faculty of Law, Ain Shams university.
Theses
-Ahmed Mahmoud Ahmed Al- Rubaie, Administrative Investigation in the public Service, a master,s thesis Submitted to the College of Law, university of Mosul, 2003.
-Hanan Muhammed Mutlaq, Judicial Control over the Appropriateness between Violation and Punishment in Disciplinary Decisions, MA Thesis Submitted to the College of Law, university of Baghdad, 1994.
-Darwish Abdel- Qader, The Duty of obedience in the public office, a master,s thesis Submitted to the faculty of Law, Ben Aknoun university, Algeria, 2008.
Legal Research
-Ekram jabber Hasssen, The effect of mitigating circumstances is disciplinary punishment (a comparative study), Research published in Journal of Psychology and Education, volume 58, issue 2, 2021.
-Ahmadi Hassan Zuwelf, Administrative Psycholo and Determinants of Administrative Behavior, research Publised in Amman, Jordan, Arab Organization for Administrative Sciences, 1982.
-Ahmed Odeh Al-Ghuwairi, The Disciplinary Authority in the Jordanian Civil Service System, a research published in the Mutah Journal for Research and Studies, Volume VII, Issue Two, 1992.
-Khaled Jamal Ahmed Mohsen, the nature of the legislative drafting and the elements of its quality, a research published in the Kuwaiti International Law College Joural, the Second Issue, the fifth year.
-Saqr Eid Fares Faleh, Freedom of Individual professional opinions of the public Employee ( Comparative Study), Research Published in the Journal of the university of Jordan, Volume Forty- Three, Issue Two, 2016.
-Ali Ahmed Abbas, Legislative Drafting and its Impact on the Application of Law, a research published in the Journal of Legal Studies, the Iraqi House of Wisdom, Issue 21, year 6, 2007.
-Muhammad Jawdat Al-Malt, Public Servant and the Exercise of freedom, research published in the Journal of Administrative Sciences, International Institute for Egyption Administrative Sciences, Volume Eleven, Issue Three, 2016.
Websites
-Ahmed Mukhtar Omar, first edition, world of Book, Cairo, 2008, published on the website: www: arabdict.com.
-Estar Fakhri Abdel Latif, The Impact of Functional Ethics in Reducing Opportuntites for Administrative Corruption in Governmental Jobs, research published in the Journal of Human Sciences, Fourth year, Isse Twenty-Ninth, 2006, published on the website:www:ulum.nl.
-Eman Abdel- Moamen Saad El-Din, Methods of Education on Virtuous Ethics, published on the website:www: gobsethics.blogspot.com.
-Hussein Bassam Lafi, Respect and Appreciation at work, 2019, published on the website: www:mawdoo3.com.
-Ebdul Mohsen Al-Jarallah Al-Kharafi, article published on the website: www:alqabas.com.
-Elwood N.Chaiman, Succeding in Human Relations: Practical Methods for Self-Developments, published on the website: www:tootshamy.com.
-Chris Edmunds, The Importance of Respect in the workplace and How to promote it, published on the website: www:annajah.net.
-The Comprehensive dictionary of meanings, published on the website: www: ebook.univeyes.com.
Constitutions and Laws
-The French Declaration of the Rights of Man and the citizen issued on August 26, 1789.
-French Employment Law No.(634) issued on 13/ 7/ 1983.
-The Jordanian Constitution promulgated in 1952, amended in 2011.
-Jordanian Civil Service Regulation No.82 of 2013 as amended.
-The Constitution of the Republic of Iraq for the year 2005 in force.
-State Employees Discipline Law No.(14) of 1991 amended by law No.(5) of 2008.
