The shift in the conditions for the civil responsibility of the parents for the harmful act of the child - a comparative study-
Keywords:
- Tort Liability. - Parents. - Children. - Liability Without Negligence. - Imposing Default. - Guaranteeing The Right. - Liability Insurance.Abstract
Abstract: Iranian law, like other legal systems, has civil liability based on fault. Article 7 of the Iranian Civil Liability Law, which is built in accordance with the general rule included in Article 1 of this law, holds the person who is observing a minor person responsible in the event that he commits an error in monitoring and following up on a minor. However, judicial procedures in France and with a different interpretation of the first, fourth and seventh paragraphs of Article 1242 of the French Civil Code amended by the 2016 reforms, It has brought about a change in orientation that attracts and is interesting and worthy of learning, which can be presented as follows: the change in orientation from the necessity of proving the parents’ negligence to the imposed negligence and in the end the separation between the basis of negligence and holding the parents responsible without negligence; On the other hand, analyzing the harmful act of the youngster according to the basis of moral negligence, qualitative negligence, then illegitimate negligence, and finally the adequacy of the causal link between the factor of harm and the harm achieved. In Iraqi law, too, the legislator imposes the responsibility of the subordinates On the basis of an assumed error in this assumption, if it is proven that the duty of care necessary to avoid the harm has been fulfilled in the required manner, or if it is proven that the harm has occurred, even if the necessary care has been taken in this case, the subordinate can get rid of this responsibility. In addition, he can get rid of Liability also if it is proven that the damage caused, stems from an external action (force majeure, the default of the third person or the default of the injured person himself) civil liability insurance has taken its form and been prepared.
References
. Patrice Jordan, Analysis of Judicial Procedures in the Field of Civil Liability, translation and investigation by Majid Adeeb, first edition, Mizan Publications, Tehran, Shamsi 1386.
4. Al-Muhaqqiq Al-Hilli: The Laws of Islam, translated by Abu Al-Qasim Ibn Ahmad Yazdi, with Sa`i Muhammad Taqi Danesh ¬ژpژoh, Part 4, 6th Edition, Volume 2, Tehran University Publications, 1371.
Abdul Majid Qaem Makami Amiri, Law of Obligations: Law of Obligations (General Theory of Civil Law Obligations), Volume One, Kayhan Publications, Tehran, Shamsi 1347.
Abu al-Qasim al-Khoei, Misbah al-Faqahah fi al-Moamalat, (Reports), by Mirza Muhammad Ali Tawhidi, first edition, third volume
Ahmad Abdul-Razzaq al-Sanhury, Mediator in Explanation of the New Civil Law, Theory of Commitment in General (Sources of Commitment), Part 1, Edition 3, Al-Halabi Human Rights Publications, Beirut - Lebanon, 2009.
Alireza Yazdanian, The Civil Responsibility of Caregivers towards the Behaviors of Persons Under Care and the Necessity of Developing it with a Comparative Study in French Law, Publication of Legal Justice, University of Tehran, No. 85, pp. 173 to 212, Spring 1393 Shamsi.
Atef Al-Naqeeb, The General Theory of Responsibility arising from the Action of Others, Second Edition, Human Rights Publications, issued, Beirut, 1999.
Fawzi Al-Mayahi, the Responsibility of the Subordinate for the Actions of His Subordinate, Sabah Law Library, Baghdad, 2016.
Hassan Ali al-Dhanon, Details in Explanation of Civil Law, Liability for the Action of Others, First Edition, Wael Publishing House, Oman, 2006.
Hassan Ali Darrudian, liabilities resulted from the actions of persons under their guardianship (liability of the guardian and protector of the young or insane one), Journal of the College of Law and Political Sciences, No. 36, Spring 1375 AH.
Maurice Nakhleh, The Mediator in Civil Liability, Part One, First Edition, House of Human Rights Publications, Sader Press, Beirut, 1992.
Muhammad Abdi, The Civil Responsibility of the Guardian of the Young or the Majnun Guardian, First Edition, Dostour Publications, Mashhad, 1395 Shamsi.
Mustafa Ibrahim Al-Zalami, Significances of Texts and Methods of Deriving Rulings in the Light of Islamic Jurisprudence, Asaad Press, Baghdad, 1983.
Nasir Katozian, Civil Responsibility, Special and Mixes responsibilities,3volumes,11th edition, Part 2, First Edition, University of Tehran Press, 1393 AH.
Prosser William: law of torts, west publishing co, third edition, 1964.
