The Rule of Law and the Principle of Legality in Criminal Law

Authors

  • Dr. Abbas Mansourabadi (Corresponding Author) Associate Professor of Criminal Law and Criminology, University of Tehran, Islamic Republic of Iran Author
  • Shahd Ahmed Al-Husseini Ph.D. Candidate in Criminal Law and Criminology, University of Tehran, Islamic Republic of Iran Author
  • Dr. Mehdi Balavi Associate Professor of Public Law, University of Tehran, Islamic Republic of Iran Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25130/0vn3rr18

Keywords:

- Rule of law - criminal legitimacy - criminalization and punishment - legal certainty non-retroactivity

Abstract

 Abstract: This research examines the structural relationship between the rule of law and the principle of the legality of criminal law. It begins with the problematic premise that the mere enactment of a criminalization and punishment in legislative form is insufficient to guarantee that the penal authority is subject to the law. A text may be formally correct, but it may remain vague, excessive, disproportionate, or subject to selective application. Therefore, the research poses a central question: What requirements does the rule of law impose on the establishment, interpretation, application, and enforcement of criminal rules, and what are the implications of adhering to these requirements? Its hypothesis is that criminal legality is not simply a matter of the principle of "no crime and no punishment except by law," but rather represents an integrated system encompassing the legality of the source, non-retroactivity, clarity, precision, predictability, minimal criminal interference, rationality, proportionality, relative stability, and oversight at all stages of the exercise of penal authority. This research aims to establish the rule of law as the theoretical and constitutional foundation of criminal legitimacy, clarify the difference between the rule of law and rule by law, and reveal areas of deviation in legislation, interpretation, application, and enforcement. The study adopted a descriptive-analytical approach, supported by historical, critical, and comparative methodologies, through the analysis of philosophical and criminal literature, constitutional and penal texts, and selected examples from Iraqi, Iranian, and international law. The study concluded that the legality of a text is a necessary condition, but insufficient for the legitimacy of coercive punishment unless the text is accompanied by clarity, necessity, proportionality, equality, and subjectness to review. The comparison showed that Iraqi and Iranian legislation recognizes the principle of legality and non-retroactivity; however, the breadth of some security formulations, the abundance of references, and the multiplicity of sources of interpretation may weaken predictability and expand discretionary power. It also demonstrated that the gravity of international crimes does not justify exceeding the bounds of legality, but rather necessitates stricter requirements of precedent and specificity. Legality also extends to investigation, evidence, trial, and the execution of penalties. Open-ended legal interpretations, broad application, and selective enforcement are all forms of governance by law. The research concluded that legal certainty, equality, prevention of arbitrariness, and public trust are the practical indicators of legitimacy, and that subjecting the power of punishment to necessity, rationality, and oversight transforms punishment from mere organized coercion into a justifiable and accountable authority.

© 2023 TUJR, College of Law, Tikrit University

 

References

1- Ambos, Kai & Rackow, Peter, (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to European Criminal Law, Cambridge University Press, 2023, Part I: “Foundations of European Criminal Law”.

2- Ashworth, Andrew and Jeremy, Horder, Principles of Criminal Law, 7th Ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013.

3- Böse, Martin, “Fundamental Rights Protection”, in Kai Ambos & Peter Rackow (Eds.), The Cambridge Companion to European Criminal Law, Cambridge University Press, 2023, pp. 231–253, DOI: 10.1017/9781108891875.015.

4- Child, John and others, Simester and Sullivan's Criminal Law: Theory and Doctrine, 8th Ed, Hart Publishing, 2022.

5- Costa, Pietro, “The rule of law: A historical introduction”. In Pietro Costa and Danilo Zolo (Eds.), The rule of law: History, theory and criticism, Springer, 2007.

6- European Court of Human Rights, Guide on Article 7 of the European Convention on Human Rights: No Punishment without Law, updated 2026.

7- Franco Peirone, “Time Clash: The Court of Justice Limits the Temporal Scope of Lex Mitior”, European Constitutional Law Review, Vol. 20, No. 4, 2024, pp. 593–614, DOI: 10.1017/S1574019624000361.

8- Fuller, Lon L., The morality of law (Rev. ed.), Yale University Press, 1969.

9- Gallant, Kenneth S., The Principle of Legality in International and Comparative Criminal Law, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009.

10- Green, Alex & Hendry, Jennifer, “Ad Hominem Criminalisation and the Rule of Law: The Egalitarian Case against Knife Crime Prevention Orders”, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Vol. 42, No. 2, 2022.

11- Hallevy, Gabriel, A Modern Treatise on the Principle of Legality in Criminal Law, Berlin: Springer, 2010.

12- Harcourt, Bernard E. "Beccaria's On Crimes and Punishments: A Mirror on the History of the Foundations of Modern Criminal Law", In Foundational Texts in Modern Criminal Law, 1st Ed, Edited by Markus D. Dubber, 39–60. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.

13- Harris, Phil, An introduction to law, 6th Ed, Cambridge University Press, 2002.

14- Khodadadi, Bahman, “Nowhere but Everywhere: The Principle of Legality and the Complexities of Judicial Discretion in Iran”, Iranian Studies, Vol. 57, No. 4, 2024.

15- Lippman, Matthew, Contemporary Criminal Law: Concepts, Cases, and Controversies, 2nd Ed, Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, 2010.

16- Meierhenrich, Jens & Loughlin, Martin, “Thinking about the Rule of Law,” in The Cambridge Companion to the Rule of Law, Cambridge University Press, 2021.

17- Muñoz, Nuria Pastor, “Why International Criminal Law Can and Should Be Conceived with Supra-Positive Law: The Non-Positivistic Nature of International Criminal Legality”, Criminal Law and Philosophy, Vol. 17, 2023.

18- Nikka, Sigrid, “Exploring Punitiveness, Exploiting Proportionality: The Ambivalent Role of Proportionality in Contemporary Criminal Law” German Law Journal, Vol. 26, No. 8, 2025.

19- Raz, Joseph, The authority of law: Essays on law and morality. Clarendon Press, 1st Ed, 1979

20- Santoro, Emilio, “The rule of law and the liberties of the English: The interpretation of Albert Venn Dicey”, In Pietro Costa and Danilo Zolo (Eds), The rule of law: History, theory and criticism, 2007.

21- Schluchter, Wolfgang, The rise of Western rationalism: Max Weber's developmental history, 1st Ed, University of California Press, 1981.

22- Shaffer, Gregory and Sandholtz, Wayne, The Rule of Law Under Pressure: A Transnational Challenge, Cambridge University Press, 2025, DOI: 10.1017/9781009460286.

23- Shirley Robin, Letwin, On the history of the idea of law, 1st Ed, Cambridge University Press, 2005.

24- Smuha, Nathalie A., “The Rule of Law in Algorithmic Rule by Law: How Algorithmic Regulation in the Public Sector Erodes the Rule of Law”, Cambridge University Press, 2024, pp. 95–150, DOI: 10.1017/9781009427500.006.

25- Tamanaha, Brian Z., “Functions of the rule of law”, In Jens Meierhenrich & Martin Loughlin (Eds.), The Cambridge companion to the rule of law, Cambridge University Press, 2021.

26- Tamanaha, Brian Z., On the Rule of Law; History, Politics, Theory, 1st Ed, Cambridge University Press, 2004.

27- Toope, Stephen J., A Rule of Law for Our New Age of Anxiety, Cambridge University Press, 1st Ed, 2023, DOI: 10.1017/9781009299435

28- Zolo, Danilo, “The rule of law: A critical reappraisal”, In Pietro Costa and Danilo Zolo (Eds.), The rule of law: History, theory and criticism, Springer, 2007.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-15

Issue

Section

Articles