Judicial oversight of administrative committees with judicial jurisdiction A Comparative Study
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25130/4z7n9j84Keywords:
Judiciary - Committees - Jurisdiction - Administrative - OversightAbstract
This research examines the subject of judicial oversight over administrative committees with judicial jurisdiction, considering it one of the contemporary legal challenges that touch upon the core principles of the rule of law and the balance of powers. The significance of this study stems from the dual nature of these committees, which combine administrative functions with judicial authority, creating a functional overlap that necessitates effective judicial oversight to prevent their transformation into absolute powers that conflict with guarantees of fair trial.
The research adopts an analytical and comparative methodology. Initially, it analyzes the theoretical framework of judicial oversight by examining the legal nature of these committees and the constitutional foundations justifying their subjection to judicial review. It also details the legal mechanisms employed in exercising this oversight and the main obstacles it faces. In its second part, the research presents applied models of judicial oversight in both the Egyptian and Moroccan legal systems, analyzing judicial precedents that have contributed to shaping the standards of such oversight.
The findings reveal that the effectiveness of judicial oversight depends on several factors, most notably the clarity of legislative texts in regulating the committees' jurisdictions, judicial independence, and the extent to which the judiciary develops oversight standards capable of balancing the requirements of technical specialization with the necessities of justice. The research concludes that guaranteeing the full right to judicial appeal against these committees' decisions is a fundamental condition for achieving legitimacy, alongside the necessity of developing specialized oversight mechanisms that correspond to the technical nature of their work.
© 2023 TUJR, College of Law, Tikrit University
References
I. Books:
1. Ahmed Abu al-Wafa, *A Concise Guide to Administrative Justice*, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2016.
2. Dr. Ibrahim Darwish, *The Right to Litigate in Arab Constitutions (A Comparative Study)*, Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Beirut, 2014.
3. Dr. Hamed Sultan, *Judicial Independence and Guarantees for Fair Litigation*, Dar Al-Shorouk, Cairo, 2009.
4. Dr. Suleiman Muhammad al-Tamawi, *Administrative Justice (Appeals for Annulment)*, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi, Cairo, 1998.
5. Dr. Abdul Aziz Abdullah al-Omar, *Judicial Review of Administrative Discretion*, International Publishing House, Riyadh, 2015.
6. Dr. Abd al-Fattah Hassan Abu Ulayya, *Constitutional Guarantees for Litigation and the Right to a Defense*, Dar Al-Jami’a Al-Jadida, Alexandria, 2012.
7. Dr. Ghazi Faisal and Dr. Adnan Ajil, *Administrative Justice*, 4th ed., Dar Al-Salam Library, Najaf, 2020.
8. Dr. Fathi Wali, *An Explanation of the Egyptian State Council Law*, University Publications House, Alexandria, 2013.
9. Dr. Maher Saleh Allawi, *Principles of Administrative Law*, Dar Al-Dhakira, Baghdad, 2022.
10. Dr. Muhammad Fuad Abd al-Basit, *Judicial Committees within the Egyptian Administrative System*, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2005.
11. Dr. Nawaf Kanaan: *Jordanian Administrative Judiciary 4*, Al-Afaq Al-Mushriqa Publishers, Jordan, 2014.
Second: Research Papers:
1. Dr. Ayman Yousef Al-Rafou’ and Dr. Bilal Hassan Al-Rawashdeh: "The Possibility of Challenging Final Administrative Decisions Issued by Administrative Bodies with Quasi-Judicial Jurisdiction on the Grounds of Misuse of Power: A Comparative Study," published in *Jordanian Journal of Law and Political Science*, Vol. 13, No. 4, 2021.
2. Dr. Tu’ayma Al-Jurf: "The Principle of Legality and Administrative Judicial Review of Administrative Acts," *Egyptian Journal of Public Law*, No. 3, 2007.
3. Dr. Mohammed Shihab Mohammed Amin and Jawan Ghareeb Ali: "Administrative Committees and Their Impact on the Right to Litigation," published in *Polytechnic Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences*, Kurdistan Region, Vol. 4, No. 1, 2023.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
تنشر مجلة جامعة تكريت للحقوق جميع المقالات بنظام الوصول المفتوح الفوري وفق رخصة المشاع الإبداعي نَسب المُصنَّف 4.0 الدولية (CC BY 4.0). يحتفظ المؤلفون بحقوق النشر، ويجوز للآخرين مشاركة العمل وتكييفه بشرط الإسناد الصحيح للمؤلف والمجلة وبيان أي تغييرات.