Human voiceprints as digital evidence and their admissibility in practice: A jurisprudential and judicial study

Authors

  • Lecturer . Salman Abdullah Jawad College of Engineering, University of Diyala, Diyala, Iraq Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25130/ensm7346

Keywords:

voiceprint - digital evidence - proof .

Abstract

 Abstract: This research examines human voiceprints as a modern method of digital evidence, particularly in light of technological advancements that have given rise to new forms of evidence based on scientific and technical principles. The unique voiceprint of each individual allows for a high degree of accuracy in identifying individuals, which raises the question of its legal admissibility as evidence.

The research aims to clarify the concept of voiceprints, their characteristics, and methods of examination, as well as to analyze their evidentiary value in light of general legal principles. This is achieved through a study of the provisions of the Law of Evidence and related laws, and by examining the positions of legal scholars and judicial applications regarding this type of evidence. The research also briefly addresses the position of Islamic jurisprudence on these modern methods of evidence, to determine their compatibility with traditional evidentiary frameworks.

Furthermore, the research employs an analytical approach, examining and analyzing legal texts and discussing judicial trends related to the study. The research concluded that voiceprints represent a modern and scientifically valuable method of proof, but their admissibility is not absolute; rather, it is subject to the judge's discretion, based on the availability of technical safeguards in the recording and analysis procedures and the judge's confidence in its integrity. The research recommended that the legislature intervene to regulate this type of evidence with clear provisions that ensure a balance between scientific advancements and the requirements of justice.

© 2023 TUJR, College of Law, Tikrit University

 

References

Sources and References

I. Legal Books

1- Hassanein Al-Muhammadi Buwadi, *Modern Scientific Methods in Criminal Evidence*, Munsha’at Al-Ma’arif, Alexandria, 2005.

2- Dr. Tarek Ibrahim Attia Al-Desouki, *Fingerprints and Their Role in Criminal Evidence*, Dar Al-Jami’a Al-Jadida, Alexandria, 2011.

3- Dr. Mohamed Hussein Mansour, *Criminal Evidence via Modern Scientific Methods*, Dar Al-Jami’a Al-Jadida, Alexandria, 2010.

4- Dr. Mahmoud Naguib Hosni, *Explanation of the Criminal Procedure Code*, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2008.

5- Dr. Mukhlis Mahmoud Hassan, "The Evidentiary Value of Electronic Means: Voiceprints and Image-based Identification," *Journal of Arts, Literature, Humanities and Social Sciences*, Issue 40, July 2019.

6- Dr. Mansour bin Mohammed Al-Ghamdi, *Biometrics: Voiceprints and Modern Technologies in Combating Crime*, Training College, Naif Arab University for Security Sciences, Riyadh, 2005.

7- Saad Ahmed Salama, *The Crime Scene*, 1st ed., 2007.

8- Abdul Karim Ali, *Technical Presumptions and Evidence in Islamic Jurisprudence*, 1st ed., Dar Al-Nafa’is, Amman, 2002.

9- Abdullah Al-Hassan, *Protection of Human Rights in Criminal Evidence*, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami’i, Alexandria, 1st ed., 2012.

10- Ammar Za’al Abdrabboh Al-Ja’afreh, *Presumptions in Civil Law: A Comparative Study*, Dar Al-Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution, Jordan, 2001. 11- Muhammad al-Ghazali, *Principles of Proof in Islamic Sharia*, Dar Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi, Beirut, 1st ed., 1968.

12- Mansour Omar al-Ma’aitah, *Forensic Evidence and Criminal Investigation*, Dar Al-Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution, 1st ed., Amman, 2009.

13- Wissam Ahmed al-Shamrout, *Presumptions and Their Role in Proving Crimes: A Comparative Jurisprudential Study*, 2007 ed., Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Beirut, Lebanon.

Second: Academic Theses and Dissertations

1- *Criminal Proof via Modern Scientific Means*, College of Law, Al-Nahrain University, 2016.

2- *The Evidentiary Value of Electronic Evidence in Criminal Proof*, College of Law, University of Baghdad, 2018.

Third: Research Papers and Studies

1- Ali Hussein, *Voice Forgery and Artificial Intelligence in Criminal Proof: A Study of the Technical Challenges Regarding Digital Audio Evidence*.

2- Sami al-Jubouri, *Digital Evidence in Modern Criminal Cases: A Legal Study on the Evidentiary Value of Digital Evidence Before Criminal Courts*.

Fourth: Laws

1- Iraqi Law of Evidence No. 107 of 1979, as amended.

2- Iraqi Code of Criminal Procedure No. 23 of 1971, as amended.

3- Iraqi Penal Code No. 111 of 1969, as amended.

4- Jordanian Penal Code No. 16 of 1960, as amended. Fifth: Judicial Decisions

1- Decisions of the Federal Court of Cassation in Iraq regarding the evidentiary weight of modern forms of evidence.

2- Decisions of the Courts of Appeal concerning matters of criminal proof.

3- *Iraqi Judiciary Journal* (Majallat al-Qada’ al-Iraqi) – Judgment of the Court of Cassation.

4- *Iraqi Judiciary Journal* (Majallat al-Qada’ al-Iraqi) – Judgment of the Court of Appeal.

Sixth: Electronic Sources

1- Ahmed Awad Ghoneim: "Identifying an Accused Person via Voiceprint," *Police Magazine* (United Arab Emirates), Issue 203, Year 17, Safar 1408 AH / October 1987 AD, p. 13.

2- "The Evidentiary Weight of Voiceprints in Criminal Proof," research paper published on the website: https://aliaws4.simple.com

3- Mahmoud Hassan (summary): "The Evidentiary Weight of Electronic Means in Proof," research paper published in the *Journal of Arts, Literature, Humanities and Social Sciences*, Issue 4, 2019.

4- Study on the subject: http://www.wipo.int/portal/index.html.en

5- Adel Issa Al-Tuwaisi: "Voiceprints: Characteristics and Uses," *Arab Journal for Security Studies and Training*, Issue 22.

6- Court of Cassation ruling dated 11/37/1967, *Journal of Judicial Rulings* (Majallat al-Ahkam).

7- Tocci (2000): *High-Tech IDs! From Fingerscans to Voice Patterns*, New York: Franklin Watts.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-15

Issue

Section

Articles