General provisions of primary and secondary disciplinary penalties and their effect on the public employee

Authors

  • Aram ghayb allah qadir College of Law and Political Science, University of Kirkuk, Kirkuk, Iraq Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25130/8jx8p017

Keywords:

- Original disciplinary sanctions - Subsidiary disciplinary sanctions - public employee - Financial implications -Administration.

Abstract

This research analyzes the legal relationship between disciplinary sanctions and consequential (subsidiary) penalties that may be imposed on public employees under the Iraqi administrative system. The study aims to clarify whether these consequential penalties represent a legitimate extension of disciplinary action or if they constitute an overreach that violates the legal safeguards afforded to public servants. The research relies on an analytical approach to relevant legal texts, along with an examination of the orientations and rulings of Iraqi administrative courts.

The study concludes that the absence of explicit legal provisions regulating consequential penalties has led to inconsistencies in both administrative and judicial interpretations regarding their legitimacy. This ambiguity has created a lack of uniformity in the application of such penalties. The findings underscore the urgent need for a clear legal framework that precisely defines the scope and conditions under which consequential penalties may be imposed. Such a framework would help strike a proper balance between the authority of the administration to enforce discipline and the employee’s right to legal protection from arbitrary or overly broad punitive measures. Therefore, a comprehensive legislative review is necessary to regulate the connection between disciplinary and consequential penalties and to reinforce the principle of legality in disciplinary procedures.

© 2023 TUJR, College of Law, Tikrit University

References

Sources

I. Linguistic Dictionaries:

1. Ali ibn Muhammad ibn Ali al-Zayn al-Jurjani, *Al-Ta’rifat* (Definitions), 1st ed., Dar al-Kutub al-Ilmiyyah, Beirut, Lebanon, 1983.

II. Books:

2. Ibrahim al-Mashahidi, *Selected Rulings of the Court of Cassation: Evidence Section*, Al-Zaman Press, Baghdad, 1991.

3. Dr. Adam Wahib al-Nadawi, *Explanation of the Law of Evidence (A Comparative, Foundational, and Applied Study)*, 3rd ed., Dar al-Qadisiyyah Press, Baghdad, 1986.

4. Dr. Adam Wahib al-Nadawi, *The Extent of the Civil Court’s Authority to Modify the Scope of a Lawsuit*, 1st ed., Dar al-Risalah for Printing, Baghdad, 1979.

5. Dr. Adam Wahib al-Nadawi, *Explanation of the Law of Evidence*, 3rd ed., Dar al-Qadisiyyah Press, Baghdad, 1986.

6. Anwar Sultan, *Nominate Contracts*, Dar al-Nahda al-Arabiyyah, Egypt, 1980.

7. Jacques Ghestin (translated by Mansour al-Qadi), *Comprehensive Treatise on Civil Law*, 1st ed., University Foundation for Studies and Publishing, 2000.

8. Saeed Saad Abd al-Salam, *Introduction to the Theory of Law*, 1st ed., Al-Wala’ al-Haditha Presses, Egypt, 2002.

9. Dr. Saeed Mubarak et al., *A Concise Guide to Nominate Contracts*, Al-Atik for Book Production, Beirut, 2018.

10. Diya Shit Khattab, *The Art of Adjudication*, [no publisher], Baghdad, 1984. 10-

11- Dr. Abd al-Razzaq Ahmad al-Sanhuri, *The Mediator in Explaining the New Civil Law*, Vol. 1, Part 2, 3rd ed., Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Beirut, 2000.

12- Ali Muhyi al-Din Ali Qara Daghi, *The Principle of Consent in Contracts*, 3rd ed., Vol. 1, Dar al-Basha'ir al-Islamiyya, Beirut, Lebanon, 2002.

13- Awad Husayn Yasin al-Ubaydi, *Interpretation of Legal Texts Based on the Legislative Rationale Derived from the Texts*, Dar wa Maktabat al-Imam, Tripoli, Lebanon, 2012.

14- Muhammad Hasan Qasim, *Introduction to the Study of Law*, Vol. 2, Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Beirut, Lebanon, 2006.

15- Dr. Muhammad Husayn Mansur, *Introduction to Law (The Legal Rule)*, Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Beirut, Lebanon, 2010.

16- Dr. Muhammad Husayn Mansur, *Theory of Law*, [no publisher], [no place of publication], 2001.

17- Muhammad Muhammad Abu Zayd, *Introduction to the Study of Law*, [no publisher], [no year of publication].

18- Mustafa Majid, *Explanation of the Real Estate Registration Law*, Vol. 2, Al-Atik for Book Printing, [no year of publication].

19- Mustafa Majid, *Explanation of the Real Estate Registration Law*, Vol. 3, Al-Atik for Book Printing, [no year of publication].

20- Dr. Mustafa Muhammad Jamal and Dr. Hamdi Abd al-Rahman, *Introduction to the Study of Law (Theory of Rights)*, Maktabat Masirat al-Hadara, Egypt, [no year of publication]. 21- Dr. Munther Al-Shawi, *Philosophy of Law*, Publications of the Iraqi Scientific Academy, Baghdad, Iraq, 1994.

22- Munther Al-Shawi, *Philosophy in Law*, Publications of the Iraqi Scientific Academy, Baghdad, 1994.

Third: University Theses and Dissertations:

A- Dissertations (Doctoral):

23- Suhaib Musa Al-Momani, *The Role of Formality in Legal Transactions*, Doctoral Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Legal Studies, Amman Arab University for Graduate Studies, Jordan, 2005.

B- Theses (Master’s):

24- Ahmed Hamza Mahdi, *Formality in Vehicle Contracts*, Master’s Thesis submitted to the College of Law, University of Babylon, Babylon, Iraq, 2012.

Fourth: Journals:

25- Mohammed Iqbal Yassin, "Formality in Certain Iraqi Laws and the Consequences of Its Absence," research paper published in the *University of Anbar Journal for Legal and Political Sciences*, College of Law, University of Anbar, Issue 1, no date of publication.

Fifth: Laws:

26- The Iraqi Civil Code (in force), Law No. 40 of 1951.

27- The Iraqi Real Estate Registration Law (in force), Law No. 43 of 1971.

28- The Iraqi Execution Law (in force), Law No. 45 of 1980.

29- The Iraqi Traffic Law (in force), Law No. 86 of 2004.

Sixth: Judicial Decisions:

30- Decision of the Federal Court of Cassation, No. 503, dated July 6, 2008. 31- Court of Cassation decision No. 104, First Expanded Panel, dated 1988/87 [sic].

32- Court of Cassation decision No. 1146, dated 18/7/1964.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-15

Issue

Section

Articles