The Admissibility of Evidence Obtained Through Artificial Intelligence in Criminal Proceedings
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25130/zm0tx397Keywords:
- Artificial Intelligence = Criminal Proof -Legal Admissibility - Black Box - Deepfake.Abstract
Abstract: Abstract: This research, entitled "The Admissibility of AI-Generated Evidence in Criminal Proceedings," evaluates AI-generated evidence from a jurisprudential and legal perspective, highlighting the procedural challenges and technological opportunities that modern algorithmic systems present to the contemporary criminal justice system.
The study's central problem lies in determining the legal nature and procedural legitimacy of AI outputs (such as biometric identification systems, smart digital searches, and virtual crime scene investigation), and the adequacy of existing provisions in the Iraqi Code of Criminal Procedure No. (23) of 1971, as amended, to accommodate and integrate them.
The research employs a descriptive-analytical approach to deconstruct the legal dimensions of these technologies, avoiding purely technical analysis and focusing instead on comparative legal grounding. The study concluded that artificial intelligence outputs fall—by way of adaptation—under the umbrella of "technical judicial evidence," which is left to the judge's discretion according to the principle of moral conviction. However, their admissibility faces significant procedural obstacles, most notably the problem of the ambiguity of the algorithmic mechanism (the "black box") and the risks of "deepfakes," which threaten the integrity of the evidence and the defendant's right to a defense.
The research concluded with a set of recommendations, the most important of which is a call for the Iraqi legislature to enact specific procedural regulations that guarantee the legitimacy of evidence obtained intelligently and regulate its digital acquisition.
© 2023 TUJR, College of Law, Tikrit University
References
Sources
I. The Holy Quran
1. The Holy Quran.
II. Constitutional Documents, Laws, and Legislation
1. Constitution of the Republic of Iraq (2005), Article 19.
2. Egyptian Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 291.
3. Egyptian Anti-Cybercrime Law (Law No. 175 of 2018), Article 11.
III. Arabic Books
1. Ibrahim, Khaled Mamdouh. (2024). *Electronic Litigation: Electronic Lawsuits and Procedures Before Courts*. Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami’i, Alexandria.
2. Al-Bushra, Mohamed Al-Amin. (2023). *Investigation of Emerging Crimes*. Naif Arab University for Security Sciences Publications, Riyadh.
3. Al-Bayati, Faris Rashid. (2024). *Artificial Intelligence in Scientific Research: Tools and Techniques for Contemporary Researchers*.
4. Harjah, Mustafa Magdy (Counselor). (1996). *Modern Judicial Encyclopedia: Criminal and Civil Evidence in Light of Jurisprudence and Judicial Precedent*.
IV. Arabic Periodicals, Research Papers, and Scientific Journals
1. Al-Barrak, Ahmed Mohammed. (2024). "The Role of Artificial Intelligence Algorithms in Criminal Justice Systems: Prospects and Challenges." *Jeel Journal of In-depth Legal Research*, Issue 60.
2. Bouattia, Mohamed Ali; and Zaarour, Abdel-Salam. *Artificial Intelligence Crimes* (previously cited).
3. Al-Jusaiman, Ali Abdullah Saif (Judge). (2023). "The Criminal Judge’s Discretion in Evaluating Evidence under Qatari Legislation," *Journal of Law for Legal and Economic Research*.
4. Al-Jakhbir, Mohamed (Dr.). (2026). "The Application of Predictive Justice Algorithms in the Criminal Justice System (A Comparative Study)," *Modern Journal of Legal Studies*, Modern University College, Palestine, Vol. 4, No. 1.
5. *The Iraqi Official Gazette* (Al-Waqai' Al-Iraqiya).
6. Al-Khalidi, Inas Mohamed. (2016). "Governance of the Use of Artificial Intelligence in Judicial Work: A Reading of the European Ethical Charter on the Use of Artificial Intelligence in Judicial Systems," *Journal of Sharia Research and Studies*.
7. Salim, Omar. "Artificial Intelligence," published research paper, p. 5. (See electronic documentation in Section Six).
8. Salim, Omar. "Artificial Intelligence," op. cit.
9. Abdel Wahab, Shadi (Dr.); Al-Ghitani, Ibrahim (Dr.); and Yahya, Sarah (Dr.). (2018). "Opportunities and Threats of Artificial Intelligence in the Next Ten Years," *Future Report* (a supplement to the periodical *Trends in Events*), Future Center for Research and Advanced Studies, Abu Dhabi, No. 27.
V. Foreign References
1. Gaetz, Abigail. "Understanding The Debate on Facial Recognition Technology in Policing: Pros, Cons, and Privacy Concerns," Available at: [https://u.pw/Ybix3](https://u.pw/Ybix3) (Last visited: 13/05/2025).
2. Russell, Stuart; and Norvig, Peter. (2020). Artificial Intelligence: A Modern Approach, p. 2.
3. Surden, H. (2019). "Artificial Intelligence and Law: An Overview", p. 23.
VI. Websites and Digital Platforms
1. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), official website: [https://www.nist.gov/](https://www.nist.gov/), accessed: 16/6/2026.
2. Noor Library digital platform, link to research by Omar Selim: [https://www.noor-book.com/كتب-Omar-Selim-pdf](https://www.noor-book.com/كتب-Omar-Selim-pdf), accessed: 26/1/2026.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
تنشر مجلة جامعة تكريت للحقوق جميع المقالات بنظام الوصول المفتوح الفوري وفق رخصة المشاع الإبداعي نَسب المُصنَّف 4.0 الدولية (CC BY 4.0). يحتفظ المؤلفون بحقوق النشر، ويجوز للآخرين مشاركة العمل وتكييفه بشرط الإسناد الصحيح للمؤلف والمجلة وبيان أي تغييرات.