حُجية الدَليل الألكتروني في الإثبات الجنائي لجرائم التَزييف العَميق

المؤلفون

  • م.م وفاء حسن مصطاف المديرية العامة للشؤون القانونية ، وزارة التربية ، العراق المؤلف

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.25130/8ar5tb57

الكلمات المفتاحية:

- التَزييف العَميق الإثبات الجنائي -الدَليل الألكترو

الملخص

يَشهد العالم المعاصر تطوراً تكنولوجياً مُتسارعاً في مجال الاتصالات، ترتّب عليه إحداث نقلة نوعية وتحول جذري في طَبيعة الوسائل المُستخدمة في نقل المعلومات وتداولها، فأصبح من المُمكن رصد الأحداث والوقائع في مختلف انحاء العالم بالصَوت والصُورة وبشكلٍ لحظي، وفي ظل هذه البيئة الرقمية برزتْ أنماط مُستحدثة من جرائم التَزييف العَميق التي تعتمد على تقنيات الذَكاء الإصطناعي في إنشاء مُحتوى مَرئي او صَوتي مُزيف يصعب تمييزه عن الحقيقة مما يُثير عدّة إشكالات قانونية معقدة لاسيما ما يتعلق منها بالإثبات الجنائي ومدى حُجية الدَليل الألكتروني وكفايته في تكوين قناعة القاضي الجنائي في ظل ما يتميز به من خصائص فنية وعلمية مُعقدة كسهولة التلاعب به او محوه او تعديله مقابل ما يوفره من دقة وسرعة في توثيق الوقائع؟ إذ يُشكل الدَليل الألكتروني ركيزة أساسية في كشف هذه الجرائم وإثباتها نظراً لكونها تُرتكب في فَضاء إفتراضي وتعتمد على وسائل رقمية بحتة، حيث تهدف الدراسة لبيان مفهوم التَزييف العَميق وخصائصه وانواعه وصُور من الجرائم الناشئة عنه، كذلك بيان مفهوم الدَليل الألكتروني ومدى حُجيته في الإثبات الجنائي لجرائم التَزييف العَميق، وقد توصلت الدراسة الى عدم وجود تشريع عراقي موحد يضم نصوصاً قانونية لجرائم التَزييف العَميق، وانما يتم الإستناد في الاحكام القضائية على القواعد العامة في قانون العقوبات رقم(111 لسنة 1969) المعدل النافذ، وبذلك فان دراسة الموضوع تتطلب تقسيم البحث الى مطلبين نبحث في المطلب الأول مفهوم التَزييف العَميق اما في المطلب الثاني فسنبحث في الدَليل الألكتروني حجة في الإثبات الجنائي.  .©

 2023, كلية القانون، جامعة تكريت

المراجع

List of Sources

I. Legal Books

1- Dr. Ahmed Abu Ataba Al-Zaabi, *Electronic Documents and Their Evidentiary Value in Judicial Proceedings: A Comparative Study*, 1st ed., Dar Al-Kitab Al-Jami’i, UAE, 2010.

2- Dr. Ahmed Awad Bilal, *The Rule of Excluding Evidence Obtained Through Unlawful Means in Comparative Criminal Procedure*, 2nd ed., Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2008.

3- Dr. Bassem Mohammed Fadel, *Legal Challenges Posed by Deepfake Technology*, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami’i, Egypt, 2025.

4- Dr. Jaafar Mohammed Al-Maghribi, *Civil Liability for Infringement of the Right to One’s Image via Mobile Phone*, 1st ed., Dar Al-Thaqafa, Amman, 2010.

5- Khaled Ayad Al-Halabi, *Investigation Procedures Involving Computers and the Internet*, Dar Al-Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution, Jordan, 2011.

6- Dr. Khaled Mamdouh Ibrahim, *Electronic Litigation in Electronic Lawsuits and Related Procedures*, 1st ed., Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami’i, Alexandria, 2007.

7- Sahar Fouad Majeed Al-Najjar, *Criminal Law in the Age of Artificial Intelligence (Deepfake Crimes Under the Microscope)*, Arab Center for Publishing and Distribution, Cairo, Egypt, 2026.

8- Adel Azzam Saqf Al-Hait, *Crimes of Defamation, Slander, and Contempt Committed via Electronic Media*, 1st ed., Dar Al-Thaqafa for Publishing and Distribution, 2011. 9- Dr. Abbas Al-Aboudi, *Challenges of Proving Facts via Electronic Documents and the Legal System’s Requirements for Overcoming Them*, 1st ed., Al-Halabi Legal Publications, Lebanon, 2010.

10- Dr. Fathi Muhammad Anwar Ezzat, *Crimes of the Modern Era*, 1st ed., Dar Al-Fikr wal-Qanun, Mansoura, 2010.

11- Dr. Muhammad Amin Al-Kharsheh, *The Admissibility of Audio and Visual Evidence in Criminal Proceedings*, Dar Al-Thaqafa, Amman, 2011.

12- Dr. Mohamed Hossam Mahmoud Lotfy, *Databases and Copyright*, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Egypt, 1999.

13- Mohamed Ali Abu Ali, *Criminal Liability for Damages Caused by Artificial Intelligence*, Dar Al-Nahda, Egypt, 2024.

14- Mohamed Mohamed Enab, *The Use of Modern Technology in Criminal Evidence*, Al-Salam Press, Egypt, 2007.

15- Mohamed Nasr Mohamed, *A Treatise on Information Crimes*, Arab Studies Center for Publishing, Egypt, 2015.

16- Mustafa Mohamed Mousa, *Criminal Investigation into Cybercrimes*, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2009.

17- Mounir Mohamed Al-Janbihi, *Internet Crimes and Methods of Combating Them*, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami’i, Alexandria, 2006.

18- Hisham Mohamed Farid Rostom, *Procedural Aspects of Information Crimes*, Al-Alat Library, Cairo, 1994.

19- Hilali Abdellah Ahmed, *Transnational Information Crimes: Methods of Counteraction According to the Budapest Convention*, 1st ed., Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2007. Second: Theses and Dissertations

1- Rafah Khudair Jayad Al-Aridhi, *Electronic Evidence and Its Impact on the Theory of Criminal Proof (A Comparative Study)*, Master’s Thesis, College of Law, University of Karbala, 2013.

2- Abdullah bin Hussein Al-Qahtani, *Developing Criminal Investigation Skills to Combat Cybercrimes*, Master’s Thesis, Naif Arab University for Security Sciences, College of Graduate Studies, Saudi Arabia, 2014.

3- Ghadir Majadib Al-Ruwaili, *Criminal Liability for the Misuse of Deepfake Technology*, Master’s Thesis, College of Criminal Justice, Naif Arab University for Security Sciences, Saudi Arabia, 2023.

4- Mohammed Ibrahim Al-Alili, *Procedural Approaches to Combating Cybercrimes*, Doctoral Dissertation, University of Sharjah, United Arab Emirates, 2023.

Third: Scientific Research Papers

1- Ahmed Kilan Abdullah, *The Evidentiary Value of Computer-Generated Documents in Criminal Proof: A Comparative Study*, Doctoral Dissertation, College of Law, University of Baghdad, 2007.

2- Ahmed Abdel-Mawjoud Zakir, *The Crime of Pornographic Deepfakes*, published in *The Legal Journal*, Faculty of Law, South Valley University, Vol. 11, No. 7, 2022.

3- Dr. Al-Asad Saleh Al-Asad, *Ethical Concerns Regarding the Negative Uses of Artificial Intelligence Technologies: The Case of Deepfake Technology*, published in *Journal of Media Studies*, Vol. 6, No. 2. 2022.

4- Ashraf Sayed Abu Al-Ela, "Criminal Confrontation of Deepfake Technology," research published in the *Journal of Legal and Economic Sciences*, Issue 66, Vol. 3, 2024.

5- Judge Khalid Hakim Latif Al-Bayati, "The Evidentiary Value of Electronic Messages," research submitted for the purpose of promotion to the third rank, 2013.

6- Esmat Abdel Majeed, "The Problem of Proof Using Modern Technological Means," research published in *Al-Qada* (The Judiciary) Journal, Issues 1 & 2, 1956.

7- Alaa El-Din Mansour Mughayrah, "Artificial Intelligence Crimes and Ways to Combat Them (Deepfake Crimes as a Model)," research published in the *International Review of Law*, College of Law, Qatar University, Vol. 13, Issue 2, 2024.

8- Mohamed Al-Amin Al-Bashari, "Investigation of Computer and Internet Crimes," 1st ed., research published by Naif Arab University for Security Sciences, Riyadh, 2004.

9- Dr. Mahmoud Salama Abdel Moneim Al-Sharif, "The Crime of 'Revenge Porn' via Deepfake Technology and Criminal Liability Therefor," *Journal of Law for Legal and Economic Research*, Faculty of Law, Alexandria University, Vol. 2, Issue 1, 2022.

10- Dr. Muhannad Hamid Obeid, "The Impact of Deepfakes in Digital Media on the Credibility of Television News Sources," research published in the *Journal of Media Studies and Research*, Vol. 3, Issue 10, 2023. 11- Judge Wissam Amin Muhammad Amin, "The Stance of Legislation and the Judiciary Regarding Crimes Committed via Facebook," a research paper submitted to the Supreme Judicial Council, 2016.

Fourth: Laws

1- The Constitution of the Republic of Iraq of 2005.

2- The Iraqi Penal Code No. 111 of 1969, as amended and currently in force.

3- The Iraqi Code of Criminal Procedure No. 23 of 1971, as amended and currently in force.

4- The Iraqi Law of Evidence No. 107 of 1979, as amended and currently in force.

Fifth: Judicial Decisions

1- Decision issued by the Supreme Judicial Council, Presidency of the Salah al-Din Court of Appeal, Salah al-Din Criminal Court (Second Chamber), Case No. 146/C2/2026, dated April 9, 2026 (unpublished).

2- Decision issued by the Supreme Judicial Council, Presidency of the Court...

التنزيلات

منشور

2026-11-15

إصدار

القسم

Articles